advice

Advice from the music editor greats

03:56

Ah, Music Journalism at Birmingham City University. The time where your tutor is the kick up the arse that you well and truly need in order to branch away from student publications and unpaid work. Pitching is hard work, you have to be firm, confident and believe in what you’re selling. Nobody buys from the quiet market seller, right?
Sending off pitches pays off. Not only do you get your work published in further fields but you’re also rewarded with valuable advice of what these editors are looking for, and how to improve your work. Here are some of the best I’ve learnt.



Jamie Milton, editor DIY
Pitched: Interview with Cullen Omori.
Advice: ‘At the moment you’re writing one short statement or narrative about Cullen, before backing it up with a quote from him. That seems to be the pattern.  If possible, I think you should vary how you integrate quotes. 
For instance:
If New Misery were a film, Cullen says bluntly “It would be directed by Gus Van Sant. Tom Sizemore would be in his house doing a ton of meth and working up the courage to kill himself. 
And at the end he decides not to, but accidentally OD’s.”
Could be…
If ‘New Misery’ were a film, it’d be directed by Gus Van Sant. Tom Sizemore would star, and according to Cullen’s plot, he’d “be in his house doing a ton of meth and working up the courage to kill himself.” It doesn’t pack a happy ending, either. “At the end he decides not to, but accidentally OD’s.”
So by doing this, you’re adding a little more of your voice to the piece and I also think it adds more flow. 
There are a couple of places within the write-up where you could switch things up with quotes. Would also contribute to cutting down the word count slightly, if done correctly.’
Outcome: of course! This made a lot more sense. Reading back, the interview was a little choppy and jumpy in places, because I was desperate to try and get everything that Cullen was telling me in. However, Jamie’s approach read like a conversation between myself and the artist. Taking this approach, I cut down about 100 words and the pitch was accepted by DIY. Keep an eye out for it published in April!

Matt Wilkinson, new music editor at NME
Pitched: Interview with Man Made
Advice: ‘I'm not that keen on massively long things for new bands - it needs to be interesting to some kid who's never heard of them, that's who you're writing for and that's who's attention you've got to keep!’
Outcome: I went and chatted to Nile Marr of Man Made, and as he’s ‘a bit of a talker’ I gathered 2000 words of transcribed words from an hour’s conversation. This was not going to be interesting for somebody who’d never heard of the band, and hadn’t got their hands on an advance of the debut album. Therefore to suit the Radar blog I had to decide what was interesting and include that. Any repetition or tangents had to be cut. I knew Nile was full of charisma, but NME is about the music. I had to weave his personality into the energy of the writing instead!
Check it out, here: http://www.nme.com/blogs/nme-radar/man-made-interviewed-nile-marr-on-manchester-debut-albums-and-dishonesty-in-music 

Joe Brine, editor at TMRW magazine
Pitched: to be a contributor
Advice: ‘In terms of writing style I like them to be feature length with conversational aspects, we rarely do question, answer, question, answer, style features.  In terms of pitching, just fire over a handful of feature suggestions and I’ll point you in the right direction with what will work for the site.’
Outcome: I’m yet to send anything over to TMRW magazine, but love reading it. With sending my interest to TMRW I asked what sorts of things they were looking for, then said what sort of music I’d be interested in covering. The feature length and conversational aspects was really helpful, as that’s the writing stance I tend to take, however some publications prefer to just have Q&As and really short, sharp pieces. Their pitching approach is useful too, as an editor Joe will discuss ideas and send opportunities out to writers to make sure each piece on the site has its own voice but similar style.

Robin Murray, editor at Clash
Pitched: Album review – The Crookes
Advice: ‘Remember a rating.’
Outcome: The review got picked up too late, unfortunately. However the advice remains clear, if you’re going to send over a piece as a pitch, make sure it fits the publication’s style guide. If they have ratings at the end, or stars – include them! It saves following emails and time. Similarly, check whether album names are in ‘Single Quotation Marks’ or maybe they’re Italic? Prove that you will fit in.

You Might Also Like

0 comments